Who do you think has the most star power among all idols, male and female, by generation?


First of all, I think

1st generation Lee Hyo-ri

2nd generation gd

3rd generation cha eunwoo

4th generation Jang Won-young

I'm not sure about the 5th generation yet



THE COMMENTS:

  1. 3rd gen is Jungkook.
  2. Isn’t 3 Jenny? I’m not sure Cha Eunwoo has star quality. He’s just handsome… As for 4, can’t think of anyone. I’d say Karina over Jang Wonyoung.
  3. reply to 2 -> Karina over Wonyoung? It depends on the person. To me, Karina, like Cha Eunwoo, feels more like just pretty than having star power.
  4. reply to 3 -> I think Cha Eunwoo does have star power—he became a household name. Even politicians use him for promo.
  5. reply to 4 -> But personally, I think star power includes appearance to some extent.
  6. 2nd gen IU.
  7. reply to 6 -> People keep forgetting IU is an idol lol.
  8. Jenny for 3rd gen, 4th gen is Wonyo and Karina, both.
  9. 3rd gen Jenny, 4th gen Wonyoung.
  10. Isn’t Jenny the 3rd gen? Cha Eunwoo is famous for his looks, but he’s not really a trendsetter or iconic kind of star.
  11. After Lee Hyori, it’s IU.
  12. reply to 11 -> I agree
  13. For me, it’s Jenny without a doubt… especially if star quality is the standard.
  14. 1st gen Lee Hyori, 2nd gen GD and IU, 3rd gen Jenny, 4th gen Jang Wonyoung
  15. Lee Hyori, GD, Jenny, Jang Wonyoung
  16. Wow but Lee Hyori really is so, so pretty and charismatic. There’s a reason she was a solo icon of her era for so long.
  17. Lee Hyori, GD, Jenny,Jang Wonyoung
  18. Lee Hyori, IU, Cha Eunwoo, Jang Wonyoung
  19. reply to 18 -> Agreed, actors feel way more untouchable than idols these days.
  20. reply to 19 -> Same, lately that’s how I feel too.
  21. reply to 20 -> 4th gen… maybe because I'm only watching dramas these days, actors feel like they have more star quality than idols.
  22. Lee Hyori GD Jennie Jang Won Young
  23. reply to 22 -> Agreed.
  24. Lee Hyori, GD, Jenny, Jang Wonyoung Seems like most people think similarly.
  25. Lee Hyori, GD, Jenny, Jang Wonyoung I think of people who are trendy or lead trends, not just pretty or charismatic.
  26. Lee Hyori, IU, Jenny, Karina (Based on current form.)
  27. Lee Hyori, IU, Jenny, Karina and Jang Wonyoung
  28. Lee Hyori, IU, Jang Wonyoung These 3 are basically agreed upon by everyone..
  29. But wow, online communities really have their own world. For me, honestly 3rd gen feels like Cha Eunwoo all the way.
  30. Lee Hyori, IU, Cha Eunwoo, Karina That’s my list.
  31. reply to 29 -> Across all gens, it’s GD tbh. Isn’t he on another level from the others mentioned?
  32. reply to 29 -> Even in public voting GD is unbeatable—he’s always No.1, then Hyori. Feels like everyone here is just listing their own biases. Is it even objective?
  33. From the comments:1st gen – Lee Hyori (undisputed), 2nd gen – GD, IU (mixed opinions), 3rd gen – Jenny, Cha Eunwoo (mixed opinions), 4th gen – Jang Wonyoung, Karina (mixed opinions)
  34. Cha Eunwoo doesn’t have star power. He’s just got a handsome face, no “it” factor.
  35. reply to 37 -> But the idea of star power really depends. Some see it as being a trendsetter like Jenny. Personally, I think it’s the ability to keep people’s attention—and that’s why I picked Cha Eunwoo. I debated hard between Jenny and Cha Eunwoo too.
  36. Lee Hyori, GD, IU…As for later gens, honestly, domestically, there’s no one that iconic anymore. Everyone’s focused more on overseas and media has changed a lot.


ORIGINAL POST HERE
Labels:

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)